Thread: Hamburg Passenger Lists 1872

Has anyone used the Hamburg Passenger Lists of 1872, and how reliable did you find them??
Reason I ask is that I've potentially found a relation (plus two daughters) but it states that she is 58, when she should be around 38... I haven't managed to see the microfilms yet, just going by the online info.
Thanks

And.. (sorry to ask) is there anyone living near a family history centre who could look at the microfilm for me if I ordered it?? Wouldn't normally ask anyone to do such a thing, but my nearest centre is difficult to get to...